played in Italy

considerations of an italian videogamer travelling in virtual worlds

Saturday, November 08, 2008

Learning from Florence

Dear friends,
I would like to make some considerations about the Rinascimento virtuale exhibit. Now, two weeks after the opening, I can make a sort of balance of this project. And I can say that the two preminent concepts I am keeping in mind are the following: this project has been a start, a beginning to show SL art in a new way in RL, and that I learnt a lot from this experience. In fact, as always happens, there were the pros and cons of making a new thing.
It has been an interesting project and I worked hard to accomplish in the best way that idea. Anyway, one can easily imagine that a project like this is very complex and demanding and not all we wanted to do could be made. By the way, many things are really Not Possible in Real Life, but I ensure that I made my best to make that thing happen.
Please consider the efforts and close an eye about the errors.
The most positive issue of this project was the possibility to show Second Life art in an important context, in an historical museum in the centre of Florence, offering to the art of Second Life a sort of legitimization. That's quite important, because here, in many cases, we are not talking about the art of people who are already known in that field but about very talented people who need to be discovered.And I can ensure you that was a big challenge: in RL there is a quite strong resistance to accept those new talents. In general the gallery owners say they prefer people with a solid artistic background: I don't subscribe to this point of view, since this way we should have missed the masterworks of Basquiat.
The second big issue was to mix Second Life art and anthropology, suggesting that SL art is not just the art of a social network but a kind of social network in itself, creating relations and documenting day by day the life of a new world.
These are the focal points of the project.
Now, as I said, I consider this exhibition as a start, useful to improve this kind of project. And I am sure that this first exhibit could represent a beginning to make some other projects. Naturally, this first one should be considered a beginning to make it better. So, please be comprehensive about all the things that could be improved. We are studying them, considering many issues and making treasure of that past experience.
I don't know yet if there will be any follow-ups, thought that some people from art centers and museums in Europe expressed their appreciation for the exhibit and for the catalog.
What is sure is that I would like to define an advisory board, since I am sure that many competences are needed to define a complex field like this in the best way: Second Life art is a huge territory and it would be interesting to share our opinions, since I noticed that some outstanding theoricists and critics had not the good occasions to meet each other. There are many studies, many features, but sometimes there is not a proper dialogue. That's a pity because there would be a lot do to: define new styles, preserving artworks, creating some sort of encyclopedia or to define an historicization of SL art.
That said, I am analyzing the format of the exhibit and I am collecting all the suggestions that arrived from the artists and the visitors. And for me the complaints (I hope they are not many) are more interesting than the compliments, since with them we will be able to improve that exhibit and to make it better, to give the good relevance and visibility to Second Life art.

3 Comments:

Blogger Harper Beresford said...

Frank--

First, let me thank you again for your hard work. I am not sure people quite realize the number of pieces that had to be solicted, compiled, made standard (from various sizes, formats, resolutions, etc.) You also had to coordinate the writing in the catalog, the MAKING of the catalog, the placement of the art in the videos, and so on. You also secured the venue.

Second, you treated the pieces as art, which is more than many would do. In the grand scheme of things, we are just a small little ant in a great big world of art and creation. The perspective is daunting, yet you were brave enough to call this art and to put your neck out to be named curator of this exhibit.

Third, I am also not sure how many people asked who was paying for all this work or what the actual costs were. I believe this must have cost a fair amount, however, and it's to your credit that none of the artists had to bear the financial burden of showing their work in this RL show.

What could have been improved, Frank, was up-front communication about the what was planned for the festival--the events surrounding the festival, the look of the show, etc. I would encourage you to, next time, handle the people part of this in a more organized fashion. Some things were not credited perfectly, some events were not publicized well to people traveling in to see the show, some questions remained unanswered for people who just didn't quite get how this was all going to work. And honestly, you aren't going to please all the people all the time.

I have a sneaking hunch, konwing you, that a lot of the events and exhibition choices were assembled at the last minute. While some people like to plan months in advance, RL doesn't always afford us that luxury when we are planning events, especially new ones. I saw photos of SL people gathering in RL, and it looked like a lot of spontaneous parties. I know that the Moleskine books were a pretty last minute idea.

If you plan to do this show again, fix those credits, plan events that are better publicized and more inclusive, and make sure the participants know what will be going on.

Thank you once again, Frank, for this unique privilege.

9:14 PM  
Blogger Loki Popinjay said...

I think this sums up my impressions That said, it was an honour to be there :-)

12:45 AM  
Blogger caLLie cLine said...

i just found out today that my dress modeled by me was turned into a banner for your show. having spent time in florence a few years ago and being 1/2 italian, it brought tears to my eyes, NEVER in all my wildest dreams would i have imagined a piece of my "art" to be shown even close to the masterpieces that are in florence, from the breath taking "duomo" to the statue of david to the ONLY painting in the world that ever made me sit and weep (it was in a church over the arno river)

so to see my "dress on my avatar" as one of the 5 banners you chose was mind blowing and i don't even know how to thank you.

also knowing there is a book with more of my creations in it and to know so many of my friends are in this book and to think ONE man had this vision and saw it to fruition is just so so exciting.

i know it must have been a true labor of love and i am seriously thinking of planning a trip to italy to see this first hand as i am just in awe of it.

(plus the best food i ever had was in florence, hahaha)

thank you so much for including me and (you did spell my name correctly) and i hope to meet you one day in both worlds.

graci, graci, graci!

dal avatar che non sa esprimere il suo ringraziamento ma trasmette
molto amore,

caLLie cLine

p.s. being in maxim's hot 100 was nice, BUT IT'S NOTHING IN COMPARISION TO THIS HONOR, TRULY THANK YOU!

2:26 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home